Sell Proxies on Etsy

MTG Proxy Reseller Program for Etsy Sellers: Let LetsProxy Print and Ship

TLDR

  • You run the storefront. We run the print shop side.
  • Your orders can ship directly to your customers with tracking, without LetsProxy branding in the package.
  • Save time with a saved Thank You Card, listing presets, and custom order uploads.
  • No extra reseller fee. You pay for the print and shipping, and we handle the boring parts that steal your day.
  • To apply: you must already have a LetsProxy account, and your application email must match that account.

The hook

Running an Etsy shop is already three jobs. You’re the designer, marketer, customer service rep, and occasionally a part-time therapist for someone who wants a refund because “my friend didn’t like blue.”

Then you add printing and fulfillment, and suddenly you’re also a production manager arguing with a printer driver that thinks “Fit to Page” is a fun prank. Ask me how I know.

If your goal is to grow, the smartest move is usually to stop doing the part that doesn’t scale: production.

What the LetsProxy reseller service actually does

This is a simple deal:

You sell your MTG proxy cards (or other custom cards) on Etsy.
We print them and ship them to your customers.

That’s it. No “learn printing” side quest. No late-night trimming sessions. No orders sitting on your desk while you promise yourself you’ll pack them “after this one quick thing.”

Brand-free shipping, in normal-person terms

Your customer gets their order with tracking, but they don’t see LetsProxy marketing materials in the package.

You still own the relationship. We just do the manufacturing and fulfillment.

Who this is for

This reseller setup is a great fit if:

  • You already have Etsy momentum and need fulfillment to stop being the bottleneck
  • You sell multiple designs and want repeatable, consistent prints
  • You get custom requests and want a clean way to handle them
  • You want to spend more time on listings, photos, SEO, and customer experience (the parts that actually grow the shop)

If you love printing and want to stay hands-on, genuinely, respect. Some people enjoy words like “bleed” and “caliper.” But if you’re here because production is eating your week, let’s fix that.

What you get with LetsProxy reseller tools

1) Custom Thank You Card editor

Create a saved Thank You Card once, and we can include it automatically with every order you place.

This is the highest ROI “branding” you can do because it costs you one setup and pays off on every shipment.

Three Thank You Card scripts you can steal

  • Simple + warm: “Thanks for supporting my shop! If anything looks off, message me and I’ll make it right.”
  • Review nudge without begging: “If you love how it turned out, a quick Etsy review helps more than you’d think.”
  • Return customer hook: “Want a matching set or custom request? Message me anytime. I love weird deck themes.”

(Yes, you can make yours cooler. Just keep it short. People actually read short.)

2) Listing management that saves your sanity

If you sell the same items repeatedly, you should not be re-uploading the same visuals and files every time.

With listing presets, you can keep your common visuals organized so selecting the right version is fast. Think of it like “saved print builds” for your Etsy catalog.

Translation: fewer clicks, fewer mistakes, fewer “why did I upload the old file again” moments.

3) Custom orders, without fighting your own listings

Sometimes a customer wants a custom order. Different art, different text, a personalized card, a weird inside joke that only makes sense in their playgroup.

No problem.

You can skip the standard listing flow and place a custom order directly. It gets handled the same way in production, it just doesn’t need to match one of your existing product setups.

4) We ship to your customers

We print and ship orders fast, and every order ships with tracking.

You get the scalability of a print partner, while your customers still feel like they’re buying from your shop.

A quick Etsy compliance note (because it saves accounts)

If you’re using a print partner to produce items based on your original designs (or buyer customization), Etsy allows that. Etsy calls this a production partner relationship, and they also expect you to disclose production partners for relevant listings.

This is not a lecture. It’s a “please don’t get your shop flagged” heads-up.

Before you apply: the 2-minute checklist

Here’s what makes onboarding painless:

  • You already have a LetsProxy account
  • Your Etsy shop name and contact info are ready to share
  • You know which products are your core repeat sellers (start with 5 to 20, not 200)
  • You have a Thank You Card message or design ready
  • You can describe your “normal” order types (single cards, sets, bundles, custom requests)

How to apply

  1. Make sure you already have a LetsProxy account.
  2. Fill out the reseller form on this page with your Etsy info and questions.
  3. Use the same email as your LetsProxy account email. If it doesn’t match, we can’t verify you and we won’t be able to set you up.

Need an account first?

Have a weird edge case or want to sanity-check your workflow before you start?

FAQs

Do you charge extra for reseller services?

No extra reseller fee. You pay for printing and shipping. The reseller tools are included to save you time.

Will my customer see LetsProxy branding?

Orders are shipped brand-free. Your customer gets tracking, but they won’t get a bunch of LetsProxy promo material in the package.

Can I include my own branding?

Yes. That’s what the Thank You Card is for. It’s the simplest “this came from my shop” touch that works at scale.

What if a customer wants a custom request?

You can place custom orders directly, even if it doesn’t match an existing listing preset.

Scroll to Top