You’ve got the decklist. You’ve got sleeves. You’ve got a game night clock that is moving faster than your shipping notifications. This FAQ is here so you can answer the important questions in under a minute and get back to brewing.
The basics
What is an MTG proxy card?
A proxy is a stand-in for a Magic: The Gathering card you do not own (or do not want to shuffle into oblivion). People use proxies to playtest decks, protect expensive cards, or make a casual group’s power level less “who spent the most this month.”
Important line we live by: a proxy is for play and testing, not for pretending it’s authentic.
Proxy vs counterfeit: what’s the difference?
A proxy is clearly a stand-in used for gameplay.
A counterfeit is made to deceive someone into thinking it’s a real card.
We’re a proxy lane shop. If the goal is “looks real enough to fool someone,” that’s not the assignment.
Are proxies allowed in Commander?
Usually, yes, as long as your pod is cool with it. Commander is a social format, and proxies are basically a Rule 0 conversation.
Are proxies allowed at an LGS?
Sometimes yes, sometimes no, sometimes “yes but only if you own the card,” sometimes “keep it to a few.” Ask first. Being upfront gets you invited back.
Are proxies allowed in sanctioned tournaments?
No, not the way most people mean it. Sanctioned events generally require authentic cards. In that context, “proxy” means a judge-issued replacement for a card that became unplayable during that event. It is not something you bring from home.
Ordering
How do I order from LetsProxy?
The intended flow is simple:
- Create your order from a deck list or file upload
- Review details (counts, backs, layout, notes)
- Checkout
- We print, cut, pack, and ship
- You get tracking
If a website makes this feel like filing taxes, it’s not you. It’s the website.
Can I order a full Commander deck? What about singles or a cube?
Yes. Full decks are the common use case, but you can also print singles and cubes. If you are building a cube, your future self will thank you for keeping everything consistent.
Can I paste a decklist from Moxfield, Archidekt, etc.?
If you can paste a clean list of card names, that’s usually enough to start. The key is making sure counts are correct and you include any tokens you actually need.
Can I change or cancel an order after checkout?
If you need to change something, contact us as soon as you can. Once an order is in production, changes get harder fast. Printing is not famous for its “undo” button.
Files, print quality, and the classic mistakes
What file format works best?
For print layouts, PDF is usually the safest because it keeps sizing and placement consistent. For single-card images, high-quality exports can work too, but PDFs reduce “why is this slightly scaled” surprises.
My last proxies were blurry. How do I avoid that?
Blurry almost always comes from the source file, not the printer. A few rules of thumb:
- Use high-resolution art (tiny images get soft when printed)
- Keep text readable (name line and mana cost matter mid-game)
- Do not let anything auto-scale (printers love “Fit to page” like it’s a hobby)
Yes, I have trusted “Fit to page” before. The cards came out perfectly sized for a different universe.
Do you check files before printing?
If something looks obviously low-res or risky, we may flag it, but your best protection is doing a quick self-check: zoom in to rules text at 100% on your screen. If it looks fuzzy there, it will not get magically sharper on paper.
Do you print custom art and altered designs?
Yes, as long as the result is still playable. “Playable” means:
- Readable name
- Readable mana cost
- Readable rules text
- Consistent look in sleeves
If your alt-art makes the name line microscopic, it might be gorgeous, but it’s also a gameplay tax.
Should I mark my proxies?
Yes. Marking proxies prevents misunderstandings and keeps you out of the “are you trying to pass these off?” zone. Easy options:
- Different card back
- Small “PROXY” label
- A consistent proxy frame treatment
Clear and calm beats clever.
Materials and finishing
Will your proxies fit sleeves and shuffle like normal cards?
That’s the goal. Size consistency matters more than most people realize. If one card is slightly off, you feel it while shuffling and you definitely feel it in a tight deck box.
What does “quality” mean for proxies?
For play, quality means:
- Crisp text
- Good contrast
- Cuts that don’t wander
- Consistent thickness and feel
- Nothing that stands out as a “marked card” in sleeves
Collector perfection is not the target. Clean gameplay is.
Do you offer foil?
Foil is a fun upgrade, but it comes with tradeoffs: glare, camera readability, and the fact that lighting will expose every choice you have ever made. If you play on webcam a lot, foil can be “hard mode.”
SpellTable and webcam play
Are proxies allowed on SpellTable?
SpellTable is a platform, not an automatic rules enforcer. Most games are casual, so proxy acceptance is table-by-table. If it’s framed like a tournament with prizes, assume “real cards only” unless the organizer says otherwise.
Will SpellTable’s card recognition work with proxies?
Sometimes. Recognition struggles when cards are altered, custom, or not in the database. Even when it works, it can be inconsistent. The practical fix is not “buy a better webcam,” it’s this:
- Reduce glare first (diffuse lighting, change the angle)
- Keep the name line high-contrast
- Use a straight-down camera angle
- Be ready to use manual search by name
Quick Rule 0 scripts that actually work
Use something short, early, and non-defensive.
The 10-second opener
“Hey, quick Rule 0: I’m running a few proxies in this deck for testing, all clearly marked. Is everyone cool with that?”
If the table hesitates
“No worries. I can swap decks, or I can find a proxy-friendly pod.”
That’s it. No debates. No essays.
Shipping, issues, and support
When will my order arrive?
Turnaround depends on what you’re printing and where it’s going. The best rule is: check the options at checkout, and remember that carriers sometimes add surprise side quests. We focus on packing well and getting you tracking so you’re not guessing.
How do I track my order?
Once your order ships, you’ll get tracking so you can follow it from label to delivery.
What if my order arrives damaged or something is wrong?
Tell us. Include a quick description and a couple photos. We’ll look at what happened and figure out the best fix. Nobody should open a proxy order and find corner dings and sadness.
How do I contact you?
Use the contact option on the site and include your order info if you have it. The faster we can find your order, the faster we can help.