Printing your own MTG proxies is usually the best route for immediate, temporary testing. Ordering physical cards makes more sense when you want a durable deck, consistent cuts, double-sided cards, or a large batch that you do not fancy trimming by hand while reconsidering every life choice that led to this moment.
The real choice is not simply “cheap versus expensive.” It is whether you need a disposable test version or a finished physical playtest deck. Start with that distinction, then choose the least annoying production method that meets it.
TLDR: DIY for iteration, online printing for the finished build
- Print at home when you need cards today, expect the list to change, or only need readable paper inserts inside sleeves.
- Order online when you want standalone cards, consistent sizing and cutting, a large Cube or deck, or properly produced double-faced cards.
- For Commander testing, print the uncertain cards first. Order the complete list only after several physical games expose the cards that looked clever in Moxfield but did nothing on the table.
- Choose a service according to the project: existing MTG printings, custom MTG-style cards, a complete Cube, or individual premium-feeling singles are different ordering tasks.
What DIY proxy printing actually involves
The low-friction home method is ordinary matte paper, printed at Actual Size or 100%, cut out, and sleeved in front of consistent backing cards. It is inexpensive, easy to revise, and perfectly adequate for testing mana curves, opening hands, combo lines, and whether your pod politely asks you to dismantle the deck.
Nine cards can fit geometrically on Letter or A4 paper, but the practical result depends on document size, printer margins, driver settings, and scaling. “Fit to page” can shrink the entire layout. A 100-card Commander list therefore needs at least 12 nine-card sheets, before mistakes, tokens, extra lands, or alternate faces enter the picture. Our guide to printing MTG cards for Commander, Cube, and deck testing covers the broader preparation workflow.
Thin paper inserts are usually preferable for temporary sleeved testing because the backing card supplies the stiffness. If you want standalone home-printed cards, roughly 250–300 gsm cover stock is a reasonable category to investigate, but GSM does not tell you thickness, opacity, stiffness, curl behavior, or whether your printer can feed it. Heavy stock and specialty media can also disagree with duplexers and tight feed paths in excitingly expensive ways. Test one sheet and compare the sleeved result with the rest of the deck before committing.
The hidden DIY costs
- Ink or toner, paper, backing cards, and sleeves
- Image preparation and page layout
- Test sheets for size, color, and margins
- Cutting 100 or more cards consistently
- Front-and-back registration for double-faced cards
- Reprinting cards after deck changes or production mistakes
DIY remains the cheapest route when you already own the equipment and value speed over finish. It becomes less attractive when the project is large, double-sided, unsleeved, or intended for repeated use.
What an online proxy service buys you
A printing service replaces layout, media handling, trimming, and much of the consistency problem with an ordering workflow. That does not make every service interchangeable. Some start with a pasted decklist, some specialize in Cubes, some sell catalog singles, and others provide broad control over uploaded faces, backs, stock, and size.
| Project | Usually the better route | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Ten uncertain Commander cards | DIY | Fast, cheap, and easy to replace after testing |
| A changing 100-card deck | DIY first, order later | Avoid paying to finish a list that is still moving |
| A stable Commander deck | Online printing | Consistent cards without cutting twelve or more sheets |
| A large Cube | Online printing | Batch production saves substantial cutting and sorting work |
| A custom MTG-style card | Verified custom-card workflow | You need control over artwork and card text, not merely printing selection |
| Maximum control over uploaded components | Specialist custom printer | Useful when exact faces, backs, stock, and deck configuration matter |
Which online route fits which MTG project?
Existing printings and decklists
ProxyFoundry is a practical route for existing MTG printings. Its current workflow supports card search or pasted decklists, available version selection, quantities starting at one card, and batches such as decks and Cube updates. The vendor lists S33 German black-core stock, UV coating, die cutting, and double-sided production for double-faced cards. Those are vendor specifications rather than independent measurements. The current ProxyFoundry ordering route does not establish an original-art creation workflow.
Its published prices currently run from $3 for one card and $2 each for two to nine cards to a reference price of $190 for 500 cards. The page does not provide one universal total for every quantity, so build the actual cart before comparing a 100-card project.
Custom MTG-style cards
For a project that needs original artwork or edited card details, PrintMTG card printing and custom MTG cards provides a verified Card Maker route. Its tool supports frame selection and editing fields such as name, mana, type, rules text, and artwork before previewing and adding the result to a print order. That is a different task from selecting an existing printing, so do not assume every decklist printer also includes a card creator.
Complete Cubes
PrintACube is the purpose-built option when the project is a Cube rather than a handful of cards. It lists ready-made examples from 360 to 720 cards and accepts decklist information for custom Cube orders. Supplying set and card numbers in Moxfield- or MTGO-style data helps identify specific printings; otherwise, the service says it uses a default version. If you are still deciding how polished the Cube needs to be, use our good, better, best framework for Cube proxies and playtesting first.
Singles and predefined sets
ProxyKing is organized around singles and predefined sets rather than a decklist-first print-on-demand flow. The vendor describes direct printing on German black-core playing-card stock, standard MTG sizing, and options including regular and foil singles or sets. That makes it more natural for filling selected slots than processing an evolving 100-card list.
Maximum production control
MakePlayingCards offers uploaded faces and backs, deck-level customization, multiple stocks, and several card sizes. Its listed poker-size options are not all identical, so selecting a generic playing-card template without checking dimensions is a bad shortcut. Review the custom game-card options and dimensions before building files.
Use a hybrid workflow for Commander
The most efficient Commander workflow is often neither fully DIY nor immediately commercial. Export the list, print the unstable cards as sleeved paper inserts, and play several real games. Track dead draws, awkward tutors, missing interaction, and cards that are unreadable across the table. Our guide to proxies for testing Commander decks before buying cards explains how to prioritize useful test copies over decorative perfection.
Once the list stops changing, order the durable version. This avoids spending money on cards that survive exactly one opening hand, while still giving the final deck consistent dimensions and handling.
Remember the sanctioned-play boundary
Home-printed and commercially printed playtest cards have the same basic sanctioned-event limitation. Wizards states that sanctioned events require authentic Magic cards, apart from the narrow case of a judge-issued proxy replacing a card damaged during that event. It separately distinguishes transparent personal playtest cards used outside sanctioned events from counterfeits. Read Wizards’ proxy policy if an event is involved.
Run one test before choosing the route
For a deck that is still changing, print one nine-card sheet at 100% or Actual Size, cut it, sleeve it with your normal backing cards, and test the result beside the rest of the deck. Check physical size, text readability, sleeve feel, show-through, and whether your printer quietly “helped” by scaling the page.
If that sheet does everything you need, keep the workflow DIY. If cutting, duplex alignment, durability, or batch size becomes the actual problem, move the stable list to the online service designed for that project. The best route is the one that gets the correct cards onto the table without turning preparation into a second hobby.
References
- How Many MTG Proxies Fit on a Page? 9-Card Layouts, Letter vs A4, and Margins – Magic: the Gathering Proxies
- Print Settings – Magic: the Gathering Proxies
- Best Cardstock for MTG Proxies: Weight, Finish, Printer Feed, and Sleeve Feel – Magic: the Gathering Proxies
- Print Proxies | Proxy Foundry
- MTG Card Maker | PrintMTG
- Print Your Own MTG Cube – Print A Cube | MTG Proxy Printing
- MTG Proxy Cubes – Print A Cube | MTG Proxy Printing
- Home – Proxy King
- Custom Game Cards Printing Design
- Low Price Wholesale Custom Cards Printing
- On Proxies, Policy, and Communication | MAGIC: THE GATHERING
